Should Dogs Wear Harnesses Instead of Collars?

One of the most common questions new dog parents ask is: should dogs wear harnesses instead of collars? The truth is, both can be safe and effective—it just depends on your dog’s needs. Here’s what you should know before choosing.

Who This Is For

New pet parents deciding between a collar and harness
Owners of dogs that pull, lunge, or have sensitive necks
Anyone who wants both style and safety in their walking gear

The Benefits of Collars

Best for holding ID tags and quick attachment (like cute collar charms!)
Comfortable for well-trained dogs who don’t pull
Lightweight and simple for everyday wear
Available in stylish materials like velvet, vegan leather, and waterproof options from Pink Papyrus

A Dalmatian dog being held by the dog owner, wearing a dark pink Antoinette Pink Papyrus dog collar.

The Benefits of Harnesses

Distributes pressure across the chest instead of the neck
Safer for pullers, puppies, and small breeds prone to trachea issues
No-pull front-clip designs help with leash training
Pink Papyrus multi-walk harnesses combine safety, comfort, and style

A French bulldog wearing the Pink Papyrus Kenna dog harness in yellow.

When to Choose a Collar

For dogs who are leash-trained and walk calmly
As an everyday option to hold ID tags
For short, relaxed walks

When to Choose a Harness

For dogs that pull or lunge
For breeds prone to breathing or neck issues
For puppies still learning leash manners
For longer walks, hikes, or active outings

Can Dogs Use Both?

Yes! Many pet parents use collars for ID and everyday wear and harnesses for walks and training. Having both means you can switch depending on the activity.

FAQs

Q: Is a harness safer than a collar?
A: For strong pullers or dogs with sensitive necks, yes. Harnesses reduce strain and provide more control.

Q: Should dogs wear collars if they use harnesses?
A: Yes. Collars are still the best way to carry ID tags in case your dog slips away.

Q: What’s the best harness for a pulling dog?
A: A front-clip or dual-clip harness is most effective for discouraging pulling.

Written by Christine Abdelmalek
Founder and SHE-E-O of Pink Papyrus
Obsessed with crafting dog accessories—beautiful, brilliantly functional, and made with love.